Accurate detection of homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) in cancer patients is paramount in clinical applications, as HRD confers sensitivity to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors. With the advances in genome sequencing technology, mutational profiling on a genome-wide scale has become readily accessible, and our knowledge of the genomic consequences of HRD has been greatly expanded and refined. Here, we review the recent advances in HRD detection methods. We examine the copy number and structural alterations that often accompany the genome instability that results from HRD, describe the advantages of mutational signature-based methods that do not rely on specific gene mutations, and review some of the existing algorithms used for HRD detection. We also discuss the choice of sequencing platforms (panel, exome, or whole-genome) and catalog the HRD detection assays used in key PARP inhibitor trials.
Purpose
Preclinical data indicate that response to radiotherapy (RT) depends on DNA damage repair. In this study, we investigated the role of mutations in genes related to DNA damage repair in treatment outcome after RT.
Materials and Methods
Patients with solid tumor who participated in next generation sequencing panel screening using biopsied tumor tissue between October 2013 and February 2019 were reviewed and 97 patients that received RT were included in this study. Best response to RT and the cumulative local recurrence rate (LRR) were compared according to absence or presence of missense, nonsense, and frameshift mutations in ATM and/or BRCA1/2.
Results
Of the 97 patients, five patients harbored mutation only in ATM, 22 in only BRCA1/2, and six in both ATM and BRCA1/2 (ATMmtBRCAmt). Propensity score matching was performed to select the control group without mutations (ATMwtBRCAwt, n=33). In total, 90 RT-treated target lesions were evaluated in 66 patients. Highest objective response rate of 80% was observed in ATMmtBRCAmt lesions (p=0.007), which was mostly durable. Furthermore, the cumulative 1-year LRR was the lowest in ATMmtBRCAmt lesions and the highest in ATMwtBRCAwt lesions (0% vs. 47.9%, p=0.008). RT-associated toxicities were observed in 10 treatments with no significant difference among the subgroups (p=0.680).
Conclusion
Tumors with ATM and BRCA1/2 mutations exhibited superior tumor response and local control after RT compared to tumors without these mutations. The results are hypothesis generating and suggest the need for integrating the tumor mutation profile of DNA repair genes during treatment planning.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
The art of war: using genetic insights to understand and harness radiation sensitivity in hematologic malignancies N. Ari Wijetunga, Joachim Yahalom, Brandon S. Imber Frontiers in Oncology.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Effects of Ataxia-Telangiectasia Mutated Variants on Radionecrosis and Local Control After Stereotactic Radiation Surgery for Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer Brain Metastases Warren Floyd, David Carpenter, Eugene Vaios, Rachel Shenker, Peter Hendrickson, Justus D. Adamson, William M. Giles, Chunhao Wang, Karen Allen, Trey Mullikin, Scott R. Floyd, John P. Kirkpatrick, Michelle Green, Zachary J. Reitman Advances in Radiation Oncology.2024; 9(1): 101320. CrossRef
Long-term survival after systemic chemotherapy, chemoradiotherapy, and maintenance therapy for an older adult patient with recurrent pancreatic acinar cell carcinoma Makiko Urabe, Kenji Ikezawa, Kazuhiro Kozumi, Yugo Kai, Ryoji Takada, Kaori Mukai, Tasuku Nakabori, Hiroyuki Uehara, Hirofumi Akita, Kazuyoshi Ohkawa Clinical Journal of Gastroenterology.2024; 17(4): 771. CrossRef
Robustness of carbon‐ion radiotherapy against DNA damage repair associated radiosensitivity variation based on a biophysical model Hans Liew, Thomas Tessonnier, Stewart Mein, Giuseppe Magro, Lars Glimelius, Elias Coniavitis, Thomas Held, Thomas Haberer, Amir Abdollahi, Jürgen Debus, Ivana Dokic, Andrea Mairani Medical Physics.2024; 51(5): 3782. CrossRef
Use of Radiation Therapy for Ataxia-Telangiectasia Mutated (ATM)-Mutation Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma: A Case Report Steven N Seyedin, Garrett Harada, Eleen Garemanian, Desiree Rafizadeh, Dalia Kaakour, Sami Dwabe, Michael Daneshvar, Nataliya Mar Cureus.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Star wars against leukemia: attacking the clones Monika M. Toma, Tomasz Skorski Leukemia.2024; 38(11): 2293. CrossRef
Predicting tumour radiosensitivity to deliver precision radiotherapy James M. Price, Asmithaa Prabhakaran, Catharine M. L. West Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology.2023; 20(2): 83. CrossRef
Locoregional Chemoradiation for a Patient with BRCA1 Stage IV Pancreatic Adenocarcinoma Pranit Singh, Jacob Adams, Sylvia Choo, Matthew Adams, Jordan McDonald, Laura Barton, Richard Levine, Dae Won Kim, Russell Palm, Jessica Frakes, Sarah Hoffe Applied Radiation Oncology.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
A genomic score to predict local control among patients with brain metastases managed with radiation Nayan Lamba, Daniel N Cagney, Paul J Catalano, Dewey Kim, Hesham Elhalawani, Daphne A Haas-Kogan, Patrick Y Wen, Nikhil Wagle, Ayal A Aizer Neuro-Oncology.2023; 25(10): 1815. CrossRef
Lineage plasticity and treatment resistance in prostate cancer: the intersection of genetics, epigenetics, and evolution Jarrell Imamura, Shinjini Ganguly, Andrew Muskara, Ross S. Liao, Jane K. Nguyen, Christopher Weight, Christopher E. Wee, Shilpa Gupta, Omar Y. Mian Frontiers in Endocrinology.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Ex Vivo Chromosomal Radiosensitivity Testing in Patients with Pathological Germline Variants in Breast Cancer High-Susceptibility Genes BReast CAncer 1 and BReast CAncer 2 Tara Zuhair Kassem, Marius Wunderle, Lukas Kuhlmann, Matthias Ruebner, Hanna Huebner, Juliane Hoyer, André Reis, Peter A. Fasching, Matthias W. Beckmann, Carolin C. Hack, Rainer Fietkau, Luitpold Distel Current Issues in Molecular Biology.2023; 45(8): 6618. CrossRef
Moving the Needle Forward in Genomically-Guided Precision Radiation Treatment Andrew Tam, Benjamin D. Mercier, Reeny M. Thomas, Eemon Tizpa, Irene G. Wong, Juncong Shi, Rishabh Garg, Heather Hampel, Stacy W. Gray, Terence Williams, Jose G. Bazan, Yun R. Li Cancers.2023; 15(22): 5314. CrossRef
Case Report: MR-Guided Adaptive Radiotherapy, Some Room to Maneuver Winnie Li, Jeff Winter, Jerusha Padayachee, Jennifer Dang, Vickie Kong, Peter Chung Frontiers in Oncology.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Dramatic response to local radiotherapy in a refractory metastatic mediastinal yolk sac tumor patient harboring a germline BRCA2 frameshift mutation: a case report Xi Cheng, Haiming Yu, Jinying Li, Xiaona Han, Erhong Meng, Houqing Zhou, Dongliang Wang, Beifang Niu, Xiaotao Zhang Cancer Biology & Therapy.2022; 23(1): 393. CrossRef
Ovarian Cancer Radiosensitivity: What Have We Understood So Far? Amelia Barcellini, Alexandra Charalampopoulou, Loris De Cecco, Andrei Fodor, Emanuela Rabaiotti, Giorgio Candotti, Simona Secondino, Angelica Facoetti, Laura Deborah Locati, Sandro Pignata, Ester Orlandi, Giorgia Mangili Life.2022; 13(1): 6. CrossRef