Effects of Complete Bladder Cuff Removal on Oncological Outcomes Following Radical Nephroureterectomy for Upper Tract Urothelial Carcinoma

Article information

Abstract

Introduction

Upper urinary tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC) is a rare disease and accounts for 7%–8% of all renal tumors and 5% of all urothelial malignancies [1–3]. The carcinoma can arise from the urothelial cells of the renal calyces, renal pelvis, or ureter [4]; thus, the recurrence of bladder urothelial carcinoma is common, occurring in 15%–50% of patients after treatment [5,6].

Radical nephroureterectomy (RNU) with bladder cuff excision (BCE) is the gold standard for the treatment of non-metastatic UTUC [7–9]. Several BCE methods have been described [4,10], however, the optimal BCE method is unclear. Complete removal of intramural portion of distal ureter should be implemented although no specific method about BCE is recommended in the current guidelines [5,11]. Several groups have evaluated the effects of different distal ureter approaches on oncological outcomes [1,7,12–19]. To date, the oncological outcomes of these method have been evaluated in only a few studies. Among them, the extravesical approach implies the possibility of incomplete elimination of intramural ureter. In a recent systematic review, extravesical incision of the bladder cuff which involves dissecting the distal ureter and bladder cuff extravesically was still performed in 30%–60% of patients who underwent RNU and intravesical incision of the bladder cuff is associated with improved intravesical recur free survival [20].

In the present study, the effects of different distal ureter approaches on the oncological outcomes was assessed in a large, single center cohort of patients treated with RNU.

Materials and Methods

Results

1. Patient baseline characteristics

Patient baseline characteristics and pathologic findings are shown in Table 1. The mean patient age was 64.8±10.8 years and 27.7% were female. The median follow-up was 37.7 months. Among the 856 patients, 477 (55.7%) underwent the TR and 379 (44.3%) underwent the EL. Groups differed significantly in the proportion of laparoscopic cases, follow-up duration, and time from RNU to IVR (p < 0.05).

Table 1

Baseline characteristics of 856 patients without previous bladder tumor history treated radical nephroureterectomy for upper tract urothelial carcinoma

2. Oncological outcomes

IVRFS for the TR and EL at 5 years were 59.9% and 49.3%, respectively (p=0.008) (Fig. 1A). At 10 years, the IVRFS was 56.3% and 45.5% for the TR and EL, respectively (p=0.028) (Fig. 1A). CSS estimates at 5 years after RNU were 82.0% and 73.8% for the TR and EL, respectively (p=0.019) (Fig. 1B), and at 10 years after RNU were 74.7% and 69.4%, respectively (p=0.213) (Fig. 1B). OS estimates at 5 years after RNU were 79.7% and 68.0% for the TR and EL, respectively (p=0.001) (Fig. 1C), and at 10 years after RNU were 61.2% and 58.4%, respectively (p=0.648) (Fig. 1C).

Fig. 1

Oncologic outcomes after radical nephroureterectomy according to bladder cuff method: intravesical recurrence-free survival (A), cancer-specific survival (B), and overall survival (C). EL, extravesical ligation; SE, standard error; TR, transvesical resection.

3. Factors affecting IVR, CSS, and OS

In multivariable Cox regression analysis, the EL was associated with IVR (hazard ratio, [HR], 1.40; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.12 to 1.75; p=0.003) compared with TR. Other predictors of IVR based on multivariable analysis included age, preoperative ureteroscopy (URS), tumor location, and pN category (Table 2). The EL was also associated with worse CSS and OS (HR, 1.47; 95% CI, 1.06 to 2.05; p=0.022 and HR, 1.52; 95% CI, 1.14 to 2.03; p=0.005, respectively). CSS and OS were also significantly associated with age, surgical approach, tumor location, pT category, pN category, and LVI in multivariable analysis.

Table 2

Multivariable Cox regression analyses predicting intravesical recurrence, CSS, and OS

4. RC-free survival and the rate of remnant ureterectomy

The number of patients who underwent RC after RNU in the TR and EL procedure groups was 11 (2.3%) and 10 (2.6%), respectively. RC-free survival estimates at 5 years after RNU were 97.3% and 95.7% for the TR and EL, respectively (p=0.352) (Fig. 2), and at 10 years after RNU were 95.0% and 95.7%, respectively (p=0.742) (Fig. 2). In addition, the number of patients who underwent remnant ureterectomy after RNU in the EL group was eight (2.1%). The mean period from RNU to remnant ureterectomy was 32.4 months.

Fig. 2

Radical cystectomy–free survival after radical nephroureterectomy according to bladder cuff method. EL, extravesical ligation; SE, standard error; TR, transvesical resection.

Discussion

Total excision of the distal ureter with its intramural portion, the ipsilateral ureteral orifice, and bladder cuff is considered necessary for optimal management of UTUC [7,8,13]. Currently, several surgical approaches are used for the management of distal ureter during RNU [1,4,5,7,12,16,21]. Among the approaches, including intravesical and extravesical BCE, involve opening the bladder [5,7,21]. However, many surgeons perform RNU and distal ureter approaches without incising the bladder but resecting the distal ureter outside the bladder near the orifice. In addition, the oncological outcomes of this method have been evaluated in only a few studies [5,20]. In the present study, the TR was associated with improved IVRFS and OS compared with EL. In addition, the TR had higher CSS although without statistical significance. The results demonstrated the incomplete distal ureteric resection is closely associated with poor oncological outcomes such as IVR, which is in agreement with previous study results. Reportedly, if the distal ureter is not appropriately removed, recurrence rates can range from 33%–75% in the ureteric remnant even in the absence of positive surgical margins [21–27].

Multivariable analysis showed the bladder cuffing method is significantly associated with IVR, CSS, and OS. In addition, N category, tumor location, and age played a significant role in IVR, CSS, and OS. Although LVI and T category (higher than T2) did not significantly affect IVR, these factors affect CSS or OS. Possibly, either IVR is not significantly associated with LVI and T category higher than T2, or occurrence of IVR is not significantly different between low and high T category. Conversely, preoperative URS significantly affected IVR but not CSS and OS. Similarly, preoperative URS was significantly associated with IVR in our previous study [28], which was confirmed in this present study. Using diagnostic tools such as CT instead of performing preoperative URS could prevent the possibility of bladder tumor recurrence following RNU.

The multivariable analysis demonstrated the type of bladder cuff significantly affects IVR and EL has detrimental effects on recurrence. Therefore, RC is expected to be performed more on patients who receive RNU using the EL due to greater IVR than in patients who receive the TR. However, RC was performed in 11 of 477 patients (2.3%) who received the TR and in 10 of 379 patients (2.6%) who received the EL. Significant difference was not observed in RC performance rate and RC-free survival. Therefore, although there was high recurrence rate of low T category bladder tumor in the EL group, recurrence of higher T category (higher than T2) bladder tumor was not likely to be affected by the type of bladder cuff. However, the results can be interpreted differently. Although the EL causes higher bladder tumor recurrences, transurethral resection of the bladder tumor (TUR-B) is performed if needed during regular follow-up. EL and TR did not show any differences based on progression of recurred low-stage bladder tumor to high stage (higher than T2) bladder tumor. Low tumor recurrence rate was observed in remnant ureter after the EL. Remnant ureterectomy was performed in only 2.1% of patients among subjects treated with the EL.

Notably, recurrent T1 bladder tumor which can be treated with only TUR-B, does not require RC. TUR-B is not an operation with as high morbidity as RC, but it is still a surgery, so it does have a certain level of morbidity. In clinical practice, many patients undergo repeated TUR-B due to multiple IVR after RNU, and repeated TUR-B is closely related to decrease in quality of life. Therefore, after RNU, the oncological outcomes, such as survival, should not be the only concern but also include the reduction of IVR. If TR reduces the IVR, this approach should be prioritized during RNU. In a number of studies, including our research, the intravesical approach was found to reduce IVR [20,21]. However, contrary results were reported in several other studies [1,7]. The reason for the contradicting outcomes between studies may be due to not considering specific conditions such as tumor location, multifocality of tumor or preoperative URS which could affect outcome. Therefore, we conducted subgroup analysis according to factors which could affect to outcome. In our results, the TR group showed significantly improved IVRFS in patients with renal pelvis tumor, with single lesion and in patients who underwent URS before RNU. In patients with ureter tumor and multiple tumors, surgeons tend to perform more TR. In the present study, all surgeons always performed TR of bladder cuff when the tumor was located in the far distal ureter which involved ureterovesical junction, which could be the reason for no significant difference in IVR rate between TR and EL when the tumor was located in the ureter. Though there is restriction to interpret these results, in the clinical practice, TR should be recommended for the patients with renal pelvis and/or single tumor as well as ureter and/or multiple lesions. Further research is needed to compare IVR between TR and EL in each specific situation.

The present study had several limitations. First, the retrospective nature of the study and non-randomized design with surgical treatment based on surgeon preference or tumor location, both introduce selection bias and are shortcomings. When considering selection bias due to tumor location, the tumor location during TR tended to be more prominent in the ureter, especially the distal ureter, but in terms of tumor location, there was no statistically significant difference between the TR and the EL group. Therefore, selection bias due to tumor location does not seem to be critical. In addition, there was no significant difference in other factors such as tumor size, pT category, grade, nodal status, resection margin status, presence of carcinoma in situ, and presence of LVI between the two groups, so the influence of selection bias due to these factors is unlikely to be large. Second, data on immediate intravesical therapy after RNU, which can have a significant effect on IVR after RNU, are not included in this study. In our center, intravesical therapy has been performed for the first time since the second half of 2018, so unfortunately, there are no data available on this. And we could not evaluate the impact of intravesical therapy on IVR after RNU. Third, the study was conducted for an extended period (1994–2018) and involved 10 different surgeons, which could also cause bias. Furthermore, subtile technical variations among surgeons in distal ureter approaches and improved techniques for BCE over the years may have confounded the overall results. Nevertheless, the research included a large sample size and extended follow-up period. According to Margulis et al. [29], UTUC recurred at a median of 10.4 months in their multicenter series of 1,363 patients [4]. Although there was wide variability in follow-up duration, the median follow-up of 37.7 months should suffice to detect most UTUC recurrences due to the natural history of the disease. Also, analysis of the bladder recurrence rate provides added value. The retrospective analysis extracted from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results database cannot provide this type of information because it is not traced [30]. In addition, the correlation between bladder cuff method and IVR was analyzed based on preoperative tumor factors, which may help surgeons select the appropriate bladder cuff method in each clinical situation.

TR of bladder cuff during RNU for UTUC was associated with improved IVRFS and OS compared with the EL. The current study confirmed that the classic complete excision of intramural portion of distal ureter should be implemented during the RNU. It is highly recommended for the surgeon to make sure that the BCE is completely performed during the RNU.

Article information Continued